Analysis of the Clinical Efficacy and Safety of a Single Upper Pole Access (SUPA-PCNL) for Staghorn Calculi: A Prospective Single Center Descriptive Study

Abstract

Introduction and Objective: The endoscopic management of staghorn calculi is very challenging owing to its complex anatomical configuration. The authors analyzed the clinical efficacy and safety of a single upper pole access PCNL (SUPA-PCNL) for Guy Stone Score (GSS) 3-4 staghorn calculi.

Methods: Prospective data collection was done on 56 consecutive patients who with GSS 3-4 staghorn calculi. All cases were treated with a standardized technique of a single upper pole access PCNL in the prone position. The patient demographics, stone characteristics, perioperative and postoperative outcomes were analyzed.

Results: The cohort exhibited diversity in age (51.7+12), gender (male to female ratio of 5.5:4.5) comorbidities, and stone burden (4.82+1.96 cm). SUPA-PCNL demonstrated a high median stonefree rate (99.5%, IQR 90-100) with minimal complications, low blood loss with a of 200cc (IQR 100-300), and median hospital stay of 3.5 days (IQR 3-5). Stone characteristics did not significantly influence outcomes. A subset required secondary treatments (12%, n=7), but overall morbidity was low (16%, n=9): (7% n=4) of which required blood transfusion, and (9% n=5) due to sepsis. The following factors were associated with increased odds of perioperative morbidity: preoperative creatinine >3 mg/dl (OR 4.19 95% Cl 0.59 – 29.71 p=0.152) and a history of endoscopic surgery (OR 7.33 95% Cl 1.20-44.96 p=0.031).

Conclusion: SUPA-PCNL is effective and safe for the treatment of staghorn calculi. In select patients, this approach obviates the need for a multi-tract access or an endoscopically-combined intrarenal surgery (ECIRS).